Unpublished draft

Empirical constraints on longevity models

NameObservationWhich models are ruled out
Frailty in natureAnimals that are elderly and frail are observed in nature, not just in the labNaive selection shadow theory: natural selection is blind to late-life frailty alleles and doesn’t get a chance to purge them
Gompertz law
CTVTA dog transmissible cancer cell line (CTVT) has persisted for 10,000+ yearsNaive intracellular accumulation/depletion models: all cells become worse over organismal lifespan because evolution couldn’t find a way to preserve a good substance or cleanse a bad substance
Immortal germlineZygote-germline-zygote cycle has persisted unbroken for 1 billion+ yearsNaive intracellular accumulation/depletion models.
Peto’s paradox
Serial cloningIn a mouse line maintained exclusively by cloning, birth rates began to decline from the 27th generation, and the 58th generation was the last
Common traits of long-living speciesSpecies known for long lifespans tend to be: 1. Low predation risk 2. Eusocial 3. Intelligent. 4. Large 5. K-strategists
Social insect longevity dimorphismIn social insects, queens and workers share the same genome, yet queens (who reproduce) live 10-30x times longer than workers (who don’t reproduce)Naive disposable soma theory: in all species, reproduction is in a resource trade-off with longevity
Avian and bat longevityBirds and bats feature active metabolism, higher body temperatures than rodents of comparable mass, and yet live many times longer than rodents.Naive “rate of living” theories: species that run their internals faster also wear out faster.
End-of-life somatic mutation burdenIn intestinal crypts among 16 mammalian species, the end-of-life mutation count per cell was very similar (around 3k mutations per lifespan) despite large variations in body mass and lifespan
Octopus lifespanDespite being decently large and very intelligent, all species of octopus live under 5 years.
Antioxidant unresponsivenessOverexpression of antioxidant enzymes fails to extend mammalian lifespanFree radical theory of aging
Caloric restriction longevityMany lifespan records in many species were set under caloric restriction conditionsNaive disposable soma theory
Dwarf longevityWithin the same species (mice, dogs), dwarf strains tend to live longer
Heterochronic parabiosis